[AHappyPhD] Journaling, The Right Now list, and the dangers of context switching


Hi Reader!

January is quickly passing by, and hopefully your New Year resolutions long-term strategy and habits are still holding up. This week, we review a key habit that helps many PhD students (and myself) better notice their daily progress. There is also a new blog post about a tiny practice to beat procrastination, and a newsletter-exclusive tiny idea that is crucial for everyday productivity.

Flashback: Journaling for the doctorate (I): Types and benefits

(Tweet-length gists of past posts, so that you don't have to read through the whole blog backlog)

Journaling is one of the practices we recommend to doctoral students in our "A Happy PhD" workshops, and it is one of the practices that has improved my own life in the past decade. This blog post looked at the types and benefits of different journaling practices:

Journaling is often recommended for well-being, but is it worth the effort and time? do different kinds of journaling have different benefits? should you take it on? It depends, yes, and it depends. More details at https://ahappyphd.org/posts/journaling-benefits/

New post: Tiny practice: Beating procrastination with The Right Now List

One of the top barriers to PhD productivity is procrastination. Have you ever found yourself with a big ugly task getting stale in your to-do list, repeatedly postponed because it is too big, too abstract, or makes you somehow uncomfortable? This tiny practice post (which will be familiar to long-time newsletter readers) gives you an simple trick to beat this sort of procrastination.

Tiny (but powerful) idea: Context switching and attention residue

See if this scenario sounds familiar: You sit down at your desk at home to work on that difficult journal paper draft. Fifteen minutes into the writing, a notification dings: an email from your supervisor with feedback about your next study design. You open the attachment, and a pang of anxiety spikes when you see that there are 63 comments on it. You remember this is not what you wanted to be doing right now, so you come back to the paper draft – but the inspiration fails to present itself. Two or three interruptions (or self-interruptions) later, you find that two hours have already passed but you have made little headway into the draft.

What is happening here? We are suffering the effects of context switching: interrupting the task we’re doing and moving our attention to another unrelated task that requires a different set of concepts and ideas to be solved. The key realization is that our brains cannot switch attention between tasks cleanly – there is what some researchers call attention residue: the ideas (and emotions!) of the interrupting task stay with us for a while, impeding our ability to complete the interrupted task even after the interruption ends. This is especially disruptive for hard, complex, cognitive tasks that require a lot of context (including most tasks at the center of PhD like writing, analyzing data, reading difficult stuff, etc.), and when the interruptions themselves are emotionally charged and/or contextually complex (like many of our emails and texts). The bottom line: most interruptions have a high cognitive cost, so we should try to minimize them if we want to be productive and make good progress in our dissertation.

Productivity guru Cal Newport has written extensively about this topic, especially in Deep Work, one of his most popular books (and a recommended read for any PhD student). Newport’s take on this is heavily informed by Gloria Mark’s extensive research on attention spans and interruptions (now also summarized in her own wider-public book on the topic, Attention Span).

Once we attune ourselves to this foible of the human mind, we start seeing it everywhere, especially in how we work for our PhD: it supports the need to remove distractions and choosing carefully where you work to prevent “priority leakage”; it aligns with the idea of working on the PhD’s “hard tasks “ in longer blocks of time (90-120 min is my personal minimum), as opposed to a “time confetti” approach; it even suggests what to do when taking a break during these hard work sessions (tl;dr something physical, not email!).

Take this tiny idea for a spin and observe how you work. But don’t make this an opportunity for self-blame and shame: rather than bringing yourself down for not having perfect focus (none of us have it – and many of our environments and technologies are engineered for interruption and distraction!), work on creating adequate habits and conditions for you to do the hard, important cognitive work of your PhD.

May your attention be where you want it to be!

PS: I’m experimenting with Amazon affiliate links, so if you click on the book links throughout the newsletter and eventually buy the book there, I may get a small benefit (without any additional cost to you).


Did this content help you? Help us spread the word (or buy us a coffee)! Forward this email to a friend you think may find this kind of advice useful. If you are reading this and you have not joined the newsletter yet, you can subscribe and get exclusive access to a worksheet to make the strategic plan towards your next dissertation goal, in the button below:

A Happy PhD

Looking for tips, tricks and advice to finish your doctoral thesis on time and with high spirits? Baffled by how little information is out there about how to support PhD students to become independent researchers? As an ex-doctoral student now co-supervising five students, I feel your pain. “A Happy PhD” is a blog (and a series of doctoral/supervisory courses) where I distil what has worked for me, as well as recent research in doctoral education, psychology and many other fields. Join our mailing list and get short doctoral advice in you inbox every week!

Read more from A Happy PhD

Hi Reader! The summer has come in full force (heatwaves, I'm looking at you!) here in the Northern hemisphere. Maybe now the teaching and other obligations are slowly receding, and many of you are rushing to finish research studies and papers before a much-needed holiday/break. This week's newsletter brings two simple but powerful tips that may be relevant in such a season: a new post about managing feedback in multi-author paper writing; and a flashback to a post where I describe a pet...

Hi Reader! After a long hiatus, made of colliding deadlines and a general "falling off the productivity wagon", we're back on track! This week, we ramp up our newsletter activity with a flashback to a post on how to face an addiction to social media, and a new tiny practice that helped me get through some of the difficult episodes in this intervening time without newsletters. Flashback: Facing addiction to social media in the PhD (Tweet-length gists of past posts, so that you don't have to...

Hi Reader! This week, we touch upon the two largest themes of our blog/newsletter. A new post in the blog continues our series on alternative ways to think about (and do) doctoral productivity. We also flash back to a post on dealing with addiction during the PhD. Oh, and you can see me talking about the actual research we do about these topics, in a recent webinar I did. New Post: Two Hundred Weeks: Productivity for Mortal PhD Students (book extract) Is there a way to be productive in our...